A Sociological Perspective
Irving Goffman's foundational work, Stigma, Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity, illuminated how societal forces sculpt our sense of self and our connections with others. Despite its critical relevance, this understanding of stigma has largely faded from the core knowledge of therapeutic fields. Recognizing how society shapes our self-perception holds transformative potential, enabling us to make choices aligned with our authentic selves rather than succumbing to social conditioning.
What is Stigma?
A stigma is a visible or known attribute that relegates an individual to a less valued social category. When someone is stigmatized:
Our perceptions and treatment become negatively biased. The person is viewed unfavorably, labeled as "defective," and positioned as an example of what not to be.
Their social standing diminishes in the eyes of others and, consequently, in their own self-perception.
They endure profound, unspoken pain stemming from a sense of fundamental unworthiness, with shame and alienation permeating their core identity.
Stigmatization

Stigmatization acts as a form of societal conditioning. By adulthood, negative judgments regarding stigmatized conditions are deeply ingrained. Individuals carrying stigmas anticipate rejection and often strive to conceal their condition, especially with invisible stigmas like addiction or sexual orientation, where deception becomes a survival tactic. Visible stigmas, such as obesity, make concealment impossible.

“A solution for the individual who can’t maintain an identity norm is to alienate him/herself from the community, which upholds the norm, or refrain from developing an attachment to the community.” (Goffman)

The root of stigmatization lies in sociopolitical power structures that dictate standards of acceptability and normalcy. Those in positions of power define "desirable" traits:
Desirability is rewarded for those who appear "together," controlled, invulnerable, and consistently agreeable.
Undesirability is punished for those who fail to maintain this facade, enforcing conformity.
Individuals unable to conform are judged as weak, immoral, or unworthy.
Shame becomes central as individuals internalize the societal judgment of their inadequacy.
Instead of acknowledging our contempt, we might feign care, driven by the "right" thing to do, which ultimately manifests as pity. Pity, however, degrades the stigmatized individual and perpetuates the game of appearances. While superficially resembling care, pity fosters emotional distance, conveying messages like, "Too bad this happened to you," or "Too bad you're an addict," implicitly reinforcing the "us vs. them" dynamic.

The Game of Appearances
The rippling effects of stigma go as far as distorting our notion of willpower and what is means to be human. For example, when in the throes of addiction, we won’t recognize the limitations of our willpower until we are forced to, until we’re “bottoming out.” Usually, it’s not until you can no longer deny the mounting problems and your life unraveling and can see that you’re out of control, that you turn the corner and seek help. Not being able to control or have the necessary will-power to control an addiction, solve the problem, make the pain go away, are often bitterly disillusioning, shame-inducing experiences.
We are conditioned to present a better image than reality.
We engage in deception of others and self to uphold appearances.
We develop unrealistic expectations of perfect control, overlooking human limitations.
We tend to idealize rather than perceive realistically.
Our relationships suffer when we prioritize maintaining idealized versions of ourselves and others. Instead of seeing each other with our inherent complexities and flaws, we exaggerate positive attributes while downplaying limitations. This "game of appearances" erects an insurmountable barrier to genuine intimacy.

Breaking Through Conditioning
Becoming aware of how social conditioning shapes our self-perception is the crucial first step toward authentic living. Recognizing the pervasive influence of stigma empowers us to:
Challenge internalized judgments about ourselves and others.
Cultivate compassion that transcends the artificial boundaries of pity.
Build relationships founded on authentic rather than idealized selves.
Make choices aligned with personal values instead of societal expectations.
By examining stigma's role in our lives, we can move beyond the game of appearances towards genuine connection and self-understanding, benefiting not only those labeled "stigmatized" but everyone entangled in the web of social conditioning.

A Case Example: Night, Mother: Stigma and Suicide
The following excerpts from Marsha Norman's play, Night, Mother, powerfully illustrate how the stigma associated with a disease (epilepsy) profoundly impacts family relationships and communication. The play centers on a mother's desperate attempts to prevent her daughter's suicide, culminating in the sound of a gunshot in the final scene.
Dialogue and Analysis:

Mama (M): I think your daddy had fits, too. I think he sat in His chair and had little fits. I read this a long time ago in a magazine, how little fits go, just little blackouts where maybe their eyes don’t even close and people just call them “thinking spells.” The magazine said that some people don’t even know they’ve had one. Jessie (J): Daddy would have known if he had fits, Mama. M: Jessie, listen to what I’m telling you. This lady had anywhere between five and five hundred fits a day and they lasted maybe fifteen seconds a piece, so that out her life, she’d only lost two weeks altogether.J: You want to talk about fits, is that it?
Analysis: Mama's initial attempt to relate to Jessie's experience by suggesting her father also had "fits" immediately highlights the stigmatized language surrounding epilepsy. By using the outdated and dismissive term "fits" and minimizing their impact as "little blackouts" or "thinking spells," Mama inadvertently perpetuates the stigma. Jessie's direct and dismissive reply, "Daddy would have known if he had fits, Mama," underscores the disconnect and her awareness of the true nature of her condition. Mama's subsequent attempt to downplay the significance of seizures by citing a magazine article further demonstrates her avoidance and minimization of the reality of epilepsy, driven by the underlying stigma.
J: Most of the time I wouldn’t know I’d had one, except when I wake up in the morning with different clothes on, feeling like I’d been run over. M: I can tell when you’re about to have one. Your eyes get this big! J: (Taking charge of this) What do they look like, the
seizures? M: (Reluctant) Different each time, Jess. J: O.K. Pick one, then. A good one. I think I want to know now. M: There’s not much to tell. You just…crumble, in a heap, like a puppet and somebody cut the strings all at once, or like the firing squad in some Mexican movie, you just slide down the wall you know. You don’t know what happens? How could you not know what happens? J: I’m busy. M: That’s not funny. J: I’m not laughing. My head turns around and I fall down and then what? M: Well, your chest squeezes in and out, and you sound like you’re gagging, sucking air in and out like you can’t breathe. J: Do it for me. Make the sound for me. M: I will not. It’s awful sounding. J: Yeah. What’s next? M: Your mouth bites down and I have to get your tongue out of the way fast, so you don’t bite yourself. J: Or you. I bite you, too, don’t I? M: You got me once real good. I had to get a tetanus shot. And then you start to turn blue and the jerks start up. J: Foaming like a mad dog the whole time. M: It’s bubbling, Jess, not foam like the washer overflowed, or, for god’s sake it’s bubbling like a baby spitting up. I go to get a wet washcloth, that’s all. And the jerks slow down and you wet yourself and its over. Two minutes tops. J: How do I get to bed? M: How do you think? J: I’m too heavy for you now. How do you do it? M: I call Dawson. But I get you cleaned up before he gets here and I make him leave before you get up. J: You could just leave me on the floor. M: I want you to wake up some place nice, O.K?
Analysis: As Jessie presses her mother to describe her seizures, the horrifying imagery Mama reluctantly reveals highlights the frightening nature of the condition, which contributes significantly to its stigma. Mama's initial reluctance and her attempts to soften the description with similes ("like a puppet," "like the firing squad") reveal her discomfort and perhaps a subconscious desire to minimize the severity.

However, the graphic details that emerge – the gagging, the biting, the turning blue, and the involuntary urination – paint a stark picture of the reality Jessie experiences. Jessie's own description of feeling "like I’d been run over" underscores the profound physical toll. Mama's actions after a seizure – cleaning Jessie up and hiding her condition from Dawson – further emphasize the secrecy and shame surrounding Jessie's epilepsy. Jessie's suggestion that she could be left on the floor reveals her own internalized sense of being a burden, a direct consequence of the stigma.

Mama's insistence on Jessie waking up "some place nice" can be interpreted as an attempt to compensate for the undignified reality of her seizures, further reinforcing the idea that her condition is something to be ashamed of.
M: The fits are over! J: It’s not the fits, Mama. M: Then it’s me for giving them to you, but I didn’t do it! Your daddy gave you those fits, Jesse. He passed them down to you like your green eyes and your straight hair. It’s not my fault! J: So what if he had little fits? It’s not inherited. I fell off of a horse. It was an accident. M: The horse wasn’t the first time, Jesse. You had a fit when you were five years old. J: I did not. M: You were eating a popsicle and down you went. He gave it to you. It’s his fault, not mine. J: Well, you took your time telling me. M: How do you tell that to a five year old?J: What did the doctor say? M: He said kid have them all of the time. He said there wasn’t anything to do but wait for another one. J: But I didn’t have another one… You mean to tell me I had fits all the time as a kid and you told me I fell down or something and it wasn’t until I had the fit when Cecil was looking that anyone bothered to find out what was wrong with me? M: It wasn’t all the time, Jesse. They changed when you started school. J: How many fits did I have? M:You never hurt yourself. I never let you out of my sight. I caught you every time. J: But you tell anybody. M: It was none of their business. J: You were ashamed. M: I didn’t want anyone to know, least of all you. J: Least of all me. Oh right, that was mine to know Mama, not yours. Did Daddy know? M: He thought… you fell down a lot. That’s what he thought. You were careless. Or maybe he thought I beat you. I don’t know what he thought. He didn’t think about it. J: Because you didn’t tell him M: If I told him about you, I’d have to tell him about him. J: I don’t like this. I don’t like this one bit.M: I didn’t think you’d like this. That’s why I didn’t tell you J: If he knew I was epileptic, Mama, I wouldn’t have ridden any horses. M: Make you feel like a freak, is that what I should have done? Maybe I did drop you, you don’t know. Maybe I fed you the wrong thing. Maybe you had a fever some time and I didn’t know soon enough. Maybe it’s a punishment. J: For what? M: I don’t know. Because of how I felt about your father. Because I didn’t want any more children. Because I smoked too much or didn’t eat right when I was carrying you. It had to be something I did. J: It does not. It’s just a sickness, not a curse. Epilepsy doesn’t mean anything. It just is.
Analysis: In this crucial exchange, Mama's desperate attempts to dissuade Jessie from suicide inadvertently reinforce the devastating impact of the stigma. Her blaming Jessie's father for her "fits" and her long-held deception about the cause of Jessie's epilepsy (claiming it was a fall from a horse) reveal the extent of her denial and fear of the social implications of the condition.
Jessie's revelation that she was having seizures as a young child, which were dismissed as simply "falling down," underscores the family's collective avoidance of the truth. Mama's admission that she never told anyone, including Jessie's father (who also had epilepsy), because "it was none of their business" and because she was "ashamed," exposes the deeply internalized stigma. Her question, "Make you feel like a freak, is that what I should have done?" reveals her misguided belief that hiding the truth was an act of protection, when it fostered secrecy and shame.
Jessie's poignant realization that her mother's concealment prevented her from understanding and managing her condition ("If he knew I was epileptic, Mama, I wouldn’t have ridden any horses") highlights the damaging consequences of stigma on an individual's life and well-being. Mama's subsequent expressions of guilt and self-blame further illustrate the internalized societal judgment associated with the condition. In stark contrast, Jessie's simple yet profound statement, "It’s just a sickness, not a curse. Epilepsy doesn’t mean anything. It just is," reveals her attempt to transcend the stigma, a perspective tragically undermined by her mother's actions.
Summary of the Case Example:
The dialogue from Night, Mother powerfully illustrates how the stigma surrounding epilepsy creates a climate of secrecy, shame, and misinformation within a family. Mama's use of dismissive language ("fits," "thinking spells"), her reluctance to acknowledge the severity of Jessie's seizures, her deliberate concealment of the condition from Jessie and her own husband, and her expressions of shame all contribute to Jessie's internalized sense of being flawed and unlovable. Despite Mama's misguided attempts to protect Jessie, her actions ultimately reinforce the negative social connotations of epilepsy and prevent Jessie from understanding and coping with her condition. Jessie's eventual suicide, while not solely attributed to the stigma, is undeniably influenced by the profound isolation and alienation fostered by her mother's desperate attempts to manage the "game of appearances." The play serves as a tragic reminder of how the fear and shame associated with stigmatized conditions can have devastating consequences on individuals and their relationships.

​